Angels Fall

Angels Fall

  • Downloads:5018
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2021-11-15 09:51:20
  • Update Date:2025-09-06
  • Status:finish
  • Author:Nora Roberts
  • ISBN:0593438590
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

#1 New York Times bestselling author Nora Roberts explores the wilds of the Grand Tetons--and the mysteries of love, murder, and madness--in this engrossing and passionate novel。

The sole survivor of a brutal crime back East, Reece Gilmore settles in Angel's Fall, Wyoming--temporarily, at least--and takes a job at a local diner。 One day, while hiking in the mountains, she peers through her binoculars and sees a couple arguing on the bank of the churning Snake River。 And suddenly, the man is on top of the woman, his hands around her throat。。。

By the time Reece reaches a gruff loner named Brody farther down the trail, the pair is gone。 And when authorities comb the area where she saw the attack, they find no trace that anyone was even there。

No one in Angel's Fall seems to believe Reece--except Brody, despite his seeming impatience and desire to keep her at arm's length。 When a series of menacing events makes it clear that someone wants her out of the way, Reece must put her trust in Brody--and herself--to find out if there is a killer in Angel's Fall, before it's too late。

Download

Reviews

Rivka

Totally guessed the killed 😎

villainess

Intriguing components dragged down by wonky pacing。 Also, I think the mystery lost its mystery a bit too early。

Judith Spence

Got MeOk you got me with this one bc I really didn’t see it coming。 As usual there was a lot more going on and sometimes that gets tedious。 Pretty good story though。

Pat M

This book was left in a home we were renting。 I can see why no one wanted to take it with them。 The first that I have read by this author and most certainly the last。 What a horrible book。 Could you make the characters more cookie-cutter and the plot any thinner? I doubt it。 Don't waste your time with this book and, if it is representative of her work, this author。 Brutal-just brutal! This book was left in a home we were renting。 I can see why no one wanted to take it with them。 The first that I have read by this author and most certainly the last。 What a horrible book。 Could you make the characters more cookie-cutter and the plot any thinner? I doubt it。 Don't waste your time with this book and, if it is representative of her work, this author。 Brutal-just brutal! 。。。more

Toria

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers。 To view it, click here。 3。7 stars。 Didn't quite love it but I'm finding I'm really enjoying reading some Nora Roberts here and there。 They have a bit of suspenseful, bit of romance/fluff and quite pleasant to read。 Not an intense reading experience but more of a bit of a relaxing read when ai don't feel for chick lit, cozy mystery or middle grade 3。7 stars。 Didn't quite love it but I'm finding I'm really enjoying reading some Nora Roberts here and there。 They have a bit of suspenseful, bit of romance/fluff and quite pleasant to read。 Not an intense reading experience but more of a bit of a relaxing read when ai don't feel for chick lit, cozy mystery or middle grade 。。。more

rania

Loved the storyThe setting was gorgeousThe story engaging and very pleasantThe characters were wonderful:One of the rare occasions I didn't hate the female characters; Reece, the female lead may be one of the few I've loved by Nora Roberts, so far (I always find them obnoxious) and I enjoyed seing her heal and evolve。 Linda-gail, her colleague and freind was a sweetheart。 There was also joanie, their boss, who was tough but also kind in her own way。The male characters were delightful as well, br Loved the storyThe setting was gorgeousThe story engaging and very pleasantThe characters were wonderful:One of the rare occasions I didn't hate the female characters; Reece, the female lead may be one of the few I've loved by Nora Roberts, so far (I always find them obnoxious) and I enjoyed seing her heal and evolve。 Linda-gail, her colleague and freind was a sweetheart。 There was also joanie, their boss, who was tough but also kind in her own way。The male characters were delightful as well, brody, the male lead, was great。 The other older ones were just endearingHaving another great romance included was definetly a plus, what I said before for the female characters applies to the romances as well。 The two in this book were better than all the ones I've already read by her。Then there was all the talk about food which made this book a definite favourite 。。。more

Matt Hardy Evite

3I would've liked it more if I didn't watch the movie first。 I love Nora Roberts' writing style but this book wasn't my type。 I thought that there were a lot of filler scenes and it's slow。 Still, it's absolutely satisfying to read。 I stan 'Ma Joanie in this story。 3I would've liked it more if I didn't watch the movie first。 I love Nora Roberts' writing style but this book wasn't my type。 I thought that there were a lot of filler scenes and it's slow。 Still, it's absolutely satisfying to read。 I stan 'Ma Joanie in this story。 。。。more

MaguiWorld

Esta es mi tercera experiencia con la autora luego de La testigo y Año Uno que me dejaron fascinada。 Por eso decidí comprar algunos libros más de ella。Debo admitir que no siento que estén a la altura de los que leí anteriormente。 No me gusta comparar, pero es inevitable。 Más allá de que no me atrapó tanto como los anteriores。。。 me atrapó。 La historia esta muy bien armada, todos los personajes tienen una base interesante y la trama es de lo más interesante。 Cuando estaba llegando al final quería Esta es mi tercera experiencia con la autora luego de La testigo y Año Uno que me dejaron fascinada。 Por eso decidí comprar algunos libros más de ella。Debo admitir que no siento que estén a la altura de los que leí anteriormente。 No me gusta comparar, pero es inevitable。 Más allá de que no me atrapó tanto como los anteriores。。。 me atrapó。 La historia esta muy bien armada, todos los personajes tienen una base interesante y la trama es de lo más interesante。 Cuando estaba llegando al final quería leer más rápido para saber qué iba a pasar y eso es algo que me gusta bastante de esta autora。Lo que no me convenció del todo es el final abrupto, siento que quedaron algunas cosas por contar。 Pero teniendo el ejemplo de La Testigo, creo que es la manera que tiene la autora de contar sus historias。 Se extiende mucho en el desarrollo, páginas y páginas (lo cual me encanta) y el final, el cierre, el moño son。。。 3 paginas。 LITERAL。 Tal vez uno esperar algo más, pero tampoco puedo decir que esto haya arruinado mi lectura。Es de lo más ligero, lo leí en menos de una semana y eso que estuve ocupada。。。 sino creo que me duraba unos 2 días。 Aún tengo otros tres libros para leer de Nora。。 veremos cómo sale esta experiencia! 。。。more

Elena Blackthorne

Angels FallI like Nora Roberts, but this book was a。complete miss for me。 Both the hero (Brody) and the heroine (Reese) left me completely cold。 I didn’t care what happened to either of them。 Brody was blunt & rude and Reese was a nutcase。 The romance was very lukewarm at best。 I didn’t even like the townspeople of Angel’s Fist and the book was slow moving & dragged。 The Murder mystery wasn’t even very interesting。 I stuck with it, hoping it would improve, but it never did。 This is far from Nora Angels FallI like Nora Roberts, but this book was a。complete miss for me。 Both the hero (Brody) and the heroine (Reese) left me completely cold。 I didn’t care what happened to either of them。 Brody was blunt & rude and Reese was a nutcase。 The romance was very lukewarm at best。 I didn’t even like the townspeople of Angel’s Fist and the book was slow moving & dragged。 The Murder mystery wasn’t even very interesting。 I stuck with it, hoping it would improve, but it never did。 This is far from Nora Roberts’ best writing。 Can’t figure out why they made it into a movie。 。。。more

Nikki

It took me a while to really sit down and read it, it kinda failed to capture at first。 But afterwards I really enjoyed it。 I feel like the "bad guy" was a bit of a cliché and I totally saw it coming, but I still found the book very enjoyable It took me a while to really sit down and read it, it kinda failed to capture at first。 But afterwards I really enjoyed it。 I feel like the "bad guy" was a bit of a cliché and I totally saw it coming, but I still found the book very enjoyable 。。。more

Beth

Quite good。 I’m probably giving it a bit more leeway than I’d normally give because it makes me want to go on vacation somewhere beautiful - and also eat classic home-cooked food at the same time - and also because that intrusive point of view Roberts often employs is barely present。 I liked this。 Impressively, in a book about claustrophobia and also small towns, the small town itself did not feel claustrophobic。 PS: Can’t say I find fresh dill to be the be-all and end-all so many cooks consider Quite good。 I’m probably giving it a bit more leeway than I’d normally give because it makes me want to go on vacation somewhere beautiful - and also eat classic home-cooked food at the same time - and also because that intrusive point of view Roberts often employs is barely present。 I liked this。 Impressively, in a book about claustrophobia and also small towns, the small town itself did not feel claustrophobic。 PS: Can’t say I find fresh dill to be the be-all and end-all so many cooks consider it to be。 PPS: Joanie-the-owner-of-half-the-town is great。 。。。more

Katie

Page-turning holiday thriller。

Rose Ann Jenny

Better than average - some good suspence, a bit of guessing about the villian。 And I liked the no-nonsence attitude of our hero。 And the imagery of Wyoming and the Tetons make me want to pay them a visit someday。。。

Ziva Drakhjärta

This was a great book about a woman who survives a brutal robbery in Boston。 All her work colleagues are killed after which she suffers from nightmares and panic attacks。 She starts being paranoid, thinking others are following her, so she moves around a lot, settles in Angel's Fist for a while, working in a restaurant as a chef。 One day, she is the single witness to a murder, but the police can't find any evidence, so they just think she's wacko。 But then unexplained things begin to happen arou This was a great book about a woman who survives a brutal robbery in Boston。 All her work colleagues are killed after which she suffers from nightmares and panic attacks。 She starts being paranoid, thinking others are following her, so she moves around a lot, settles in Angel's Fist for a while, working in a restaurant as a chef。 One day, she is the single witness to a murder, but the police can't find any evidence, so they just think she's wacko。 But then unexplained things begin to happen around her, so she starts to believe it is true - maybe she is mad?This was an excellent mystery with a fabulous twist。 I won't spoil the rest, but trust me, this is one of Roberts' better books。 I really enjoyed it。 It was entertaining from start to finish, and FOR ONCE, the love story was slow and sultry, and I very much enjoyed it。 。。。more

Victoria

This would've been an easy 5 stars if the ending wouldn't have been so predictable from the beginning。 This would've been an easy 5 stars if the ending wouldn't have been so predictable from the beginning。 。。。more

Megan

Great read!!

Kristy Marquez

I loved this book, I think it's possible I didn't read it when it came out, not sure how I missed it, but this was absolutely awesome。 A new favorite。 I loved this book, I think it's possible I didn't read it when it came out, not sure how I missed it, but this was absolutely awesome。 A new favorite。 。。。more

Laine

Sex scenes are not enough to cover up too many holes, especially in the ending。 The sole survivor of a mass shooting of 12 when the killers are still at large is going to publish a cookbook under her own name so they can find her easily to remove the sole witness? (She supposedly saw nothing useful but how can the killers be sure of that?) A well known town citizen can move in and out of the heroine's apartment on top of her restaurant workplace half a dozen times to do minor mischief without an Sex scenes are not enough to cover up too many holes, especially in the ending。 The sole survivor of a mass shooting of 12 when the killers are still at large is going to publish a cookbook under her own name so they can find her easily to remove the sole witness? (She supposedly saw nothing useful but how can the killers be sure of that?) A well known town citizen can move in and out of the heroine's apartment on top of her restaurant workplace half a dozen times to do minor mischief without anyone noticing? Somebody's grandfather's rifle is loaded and fires after who knows how many years in a glass case in a rental cabin? A guy who can't scrape up $10,000 blackmail money gave a $3000。 necklace to two women, one of whom was so low rent she would have been satisfied with a $50 pair of earrings? Even with binoculars, the heroine got a good enough look at a murder victim across a river to describe her to an amateur sketch artist whose portrait was accurate enough that someone recognized the subject? Yeah, sure。 。。。more

Diane Engelkens

My favorite Roberts book, followed closely by Northern Lights。 I have read both repeatedly。 Definitely follows the script for a typical Roberts book。

Ronda

I loved the humor that this book held along with the suspense。

Lauren

Angels Fall4 StarsIn the aftermath of a traumatic event, Reese Gilmore is on a journey of healing and self-discovery when she arrives in the small town of Angel's Fist and finds herself putting down stakes。 Life seems to be looking up for Reese until she witnesses a brutal murder while hiking in the mountains。 Reese's past and a lack of evidence at the crime scene lead the police and many of the townsfolk to question Reese's account, but local author, Jamison Brody, is convinced and the two join Angels Fall4 StarsIn the aftermath of a traumatic event, Reese Gilmore is on a journey of healing and self-discovery when she arrives in the small town of Angel's Fist and finds herself putting down stakes。 Life seems to be looking up for Reese until she witnesses a brutal murder while hiking in the mountains。 Reese's past and a lack of evidence at the crime scene lead the police and many of the townsfolk to question Reese's account, but local author, Jamison Brody, is convinced and the two join forces to uncover the truth。 As this book is a re-read, I decided to listen to the audiobook narrated by Joyce Bean this time around。 While Bean is not a go-to narrator for me, she does a very good job with both the male and female voices。 She delivers Brody's cranky one-liners with aplomb and prevents Reese from sounding too overwrought and whiny。Brody is definitely a different type of hero for Nora。 It was difficult to like him at first because of his abrasive personality, but he eventually grew on me precisely because of his straightforward no-nonsense manner。 It is very clear that he truly cares about Reece, believes in her, and does not pity her, which is exactly what she needs。Reese is a likable heroine as, despite her apparent emotional fragility, she is a strong and resilient survivor。 The fact that she doesn't cave to the villain's decidedly malicious tricks is a testament to her strength of character。 As a re-read, the identity of the killer was not a mystery, but it was fun retracing Reese and Brody's journey and the last few chapters are intense and exciting。 That said, the book is in dire need of an epilogue with the reactions of all of the other characters to the revelation of the truth。 Overall, an engaging read, and I particularly enjoyed the small-town vibe and supporting cast。 。。。more

Georgia Brady

A perfect combination of thriller, romance, and mystery。

Stephanie

I've read a few books in the In Death series that Nora Roberts writes as J。D。 Robb, but Angels Fall is the first actual Nora Roberts book that I have read。 I have always associated Nora Roberts books as being romance, but Angels Fall is more suspense。 It still has romance in it, but it's more about Reece Gilmore's struggles to get control of her life after a tragic event happened that prompted her to move from Boston to a small town in Wyoming。Just when Reece starts feeling comfortable and start I've read a few books in the In Death series that Nora Roberts writes as J。D。 Robb, but Angels Fall is the first actual Nora Roberts book that I have read。 I have always associated Nora Roberts books as being romance, but Angels Fall is more suspense。 It still has romance in it, but it's more about Reece Gilmore's struggles to get control of her life after a tragic event happened that prompted her to move from Boston to a small town in Wyoming。Just when Reece starts feeling comfortable and starts imagining her future, she witnesses a woman being attacked。 She quickly finds that the town is a little skeptical due to her past and that she's an outsider。 It doesn't help when little things start happening to make the townsfolk and Reece start questioning her sanity。I have driven through the Jackson Hole area and this book made me want to go back。 It was so easy to vividly imagine the majestic Tetons and the beautiful meadows。 All of the characters felt real and I especially liked how Reece slowly and subtly transformed throughout the book。 I look forward to reading more of Nora Roberts' books like this! 。。。more

Billie Krutsch

This was truly in Nora Roberts style。 I like these stand alone books better than the 3 book series。 There was people falling in love。 Perfect descriptions of the beautiful scenery of the Teton mountains。 There was a murder。 I didn't figure out the killer until the very end。 This was truly in Nora Roberts style。 I like these stand alone books better than the 3 book series。 There was people falling in love。 Perfect descriptions of the beautiful scenery of the Teton mountains。 There was a murder。 I didn't figure out the killer until the very end。 。。。more

Martha Hart

Was okay。 Tired of over traumatize women。 Decent twist with the bad guy。

Jay Beatrice

Good。 A bit slow。 Maybe because audiobook。

صديقة السماء

ليست سيئة ولسوء الحظ لم تكن بتلك الجودة ايضا。。أقاصدٌ إياها بحثا عن الدراما ؟ الفلسفة ؟ أدب ؟ علم نفس/اجتماع؟ حبكة مدوية؟ عاطفة/رومانسية ؟ لن تجد ايًا من ذلك ، أو حري بي قول أنك لن تروي عطشك لايٍ مما سبق، من كل بحر قطرة ولكن بطريقة لم استلطفها البته 。عن الروايةريسي فتاة المدينة التي تتنقل للريف بعد حادث مروع ألمّ بها ومأساة لا زالت عالقة في تفاصيلها، لا ترف لها عين دون أن تلمح ذكرى من هنا أو طيفًا مما حدث ، لشهور طوال عالقة بين ثنايا حزنها ومكبلة بعجزها أمام مشاعر الأسى والذنب التي تنام إلى جوار ليست سيئة ولسوء الحظ لم تكن بتلك الجودة ايضا。。أقاصدٌ إياها بحثا عن الدراما ؟ الفلسفة ؟ أدب ؟ علم نفس/اجتماع؟ حبكة مدوية؟ عاطفة/رومانسية ؟ لن تجد ايًا من ذلك ، أو حري بي قول أنك لن تروي عطشك لايٍ مما سبق، من كل بحر قطرة ولكن بطريقة لم استلطفها البته 。عن الروايةريسي فتاة المدينة التي تتنقل للريف بعد حادث مروع ألمّ بها ومأساة لا زالت عالقة في تفاصيلها، لا ترف لها عين دون أن تلمح ذكرى من هنا أو طيفًا مما حدث ، لشهور طوال عالقة بين ثنايا حزنها ومكبلة بعجزها أمام مشاعر الأسى والذنب التي تنام إلى جوارها كل ليلة -إن حالفها الحظ بالنوم- 。。بعد أن تنتقل للريف ويقع اختيارها على انجيل فيست ، لا لرغبة في نفسها إنما استجابة للقدر وللعلامات التي خلفها وراءَهُ "لها"، تبدأ حياتها بالسكون。。 ويتراءى لها من بعيد حلمها الذي طال انتظاره بالاستقرار والتخطي 。。 أهذا كل ما تطلبه الامر لكي تنسى ما حدث ؟ هل ستهديها انجيل فيست فرصتها المنتظرة لعيش حياة طبيعية؟ بعيدا عن عن ذكريات الشرق المنتنة؟ وأخيرًا ستتوشح رحلتها الشاقة بالنصر و تتغلب فتاة الريف على فتاة الشرق وأشباحها؟! ** لا تقرأ الفقرة التالية إن كان للتشويق من ميزانك حيز ، فأنا على وشك الخوض بالأحداث **الحبكة ضعييفة جدًا ، لا أصدق أنه وفقط هكذا تنتهي! أهذا كل ما بجعبتك يا نورا روبرتس ؟ أعلم أنني قصدتها سعيا لقضاء وقتٍ ممتعٍ لا أكثر ولكن بنهاية كتلك لا أطيق تذكرًا أني قضيت أيامي الاربعة الماضية برفقتها 。。 وصولا الى الفصل الأخير كان لا زال يلازمني الأمل او دعنا نقول 'ثقة' بأنها لن تنتهي نهاية أسمى ما يقال عنها "تقليدية"ليس وكأنه لم يطرق ذهني كون ريك القاتل لكن 。。 كان هذا الخيار مستبعدًا تماما لأنه اكثر من واضح 。。 أكثر من عادي ، من يسره إنهاء روياته البوليسية بهذة الطريقة؟ واقعية اكثر من اللازم، مستتبة أكثر من المطلوب، متوقعة بصورة لا يرجوها قارئ 。。 لستمتعت أكثر بقراة الجريدة إذًا إن كان هذا ما أبحث عنه! كنت لأفضل نهاية تستيقظ فيها ريسي في غرفة بيضاء وبرداء المرضى الأخضر لتجد أن ما سبق كله حلم وأنها ما زالت تحت تأثير الصدمة -رغم مرارتها- على أن يقابل حماسي بخيبةأظنه خطأي ، لمن العار أن تقرأ رواية دراما/جريمة وأنت أحد رواد رويات أجاثا كريستي ، رغم خلوها من الرومانسية التي لا تغيب عن كتابات نورا والتي تكون في بعض الاحيان إضافة جميلة ورحلة مبهجة للعقل بعيدًا عن إعماله ، إلا اني لا أذكر نهاية لها لحقتها خيبة وإن كان من العجلة الحكم وانا لا زلت في مرحلة استكشاف أعمالها**نهاية الحديث عن الأحداث**أخيرًا لم أندم على قراءتها والسبب الوحيد لذلك هو سعيي لقضاء وقت ممتع برفقة كتاب بغض النظر عن عائده علي ، وإلا لكان لي كلام آخر 。 ولكن مما لا شك فيه أنّ ما قرأته بجل حبكته و تعقيداته كان من الممكن تضمينه في رواية أقصر ، أقصر بكثييير وكنت حينها سأكون أقل حسرة على الوقت الذي رافقتني فيه 。。قد أكون أجحفت بحق الحبكة والعُقَد التي اختارتها الكاتبة ولكن شخصيًا لم ترق لي، ولم ترتق لكلٍ من تطلعاتي وتوقعاتي! ربما تقييمي شديد الصرامة ولكن ذائقتي الأدببية تستحق ما يقوم مقامها وإن كنت سأنحي جانبًا بعض ما تمليه علي نفسي حين أشرع في إختيار كتاب من سعيٍ للفائدة واقتناصٍ لما يحمد عاقبته وولعًا شديد بلغة الكاتب فحينها لا أتوقع أقل من متعة بالغة او هواجس لا تفارقني لليالي بعد انتهائي 。。 ورغم كوني لم أنهِها إلا منذ دقائق الا أنني متأكدة أن هذا لن يحصل 。。。more

☘ Lily ☘

My experience with NR actually started with this book。 Well, technically it was the adaptation of this book。 In fact, I was a kid when I watched the movie on tv and I was so intrigued by the book itself。 Fast forward a decade and so later, here I am。Reece is a mass shooting survivor and seeking for a job in a small lakeside town in Wyoming。 She wasn't fully healed from the ordeal when one day she witnessed a murder。 However, when the police checked out the site, there was no trace of any killing My experience with NR actually started with this book。 Well, technically it was the adaptation of this book。 In fact, I was a kid when I watched the movie on tv and I was so intrigued by the book itself。 Fast forward a decade and so later, here I am。Reece is a mass shooting survivor and seeking for a job in a small lakeside town in Wyoming。 She wasn't fully healed from the ordeal when one day she witnessed a murder。 However, when the police checked out the site, there was no trace of any killing happened。While some people were trying to discredit her, Brody, a mystery/thriller writer believed in her and trying alongside her to discover the mystery of the suspected murder。Okay, now onto my favourite part of the book, which maybe a little controversial。 The hero。 Brody is not your typical NR hero (at least from my five books experience)。 He's almost unlikable in some way。 He's insensitive, brusque, rude, and in a way he would've preferred, callous。 “I was in a psych ward for three months。 Being called a maniac doesn’t hurt my feelings。”“Maybe you should’ve given it a few more weeks。”“That’s the first time I’ve kissed a man in two years。”“No wonder you’re crazy。。。”But damn if that doesn't make him interesting in my head。 "You told me once before you were hot for neurotics。”“Yeah, I did。 Not only is there a difference between hysteria and neurosis, I’ve decided you’re not neurotic enough for me。 So I’m just going to use you until something better comes along。”Now onto some of the downside of this book。 The mystery is really not up to par in comparison to newer NR works (and her J。D。 Robb ones)。 It's so easy and the guilty party is so obvious I want to shake everyone's head for being so blind。 。。。more

Lotus。Lua

Siempre es una delicia leer sus libros。。。Una descripción diferente del carácter de la protagonista pero su progreso y capacidad de seguir adelante es muy relevante。

Kami Dodson-Perry

This is the first book I have read from Nora Roberts。 I really liked it。The main character Reece is awesome。 Her spirit, tenacity, strength, and even her stubbornness is great。 She has some problems, but who doesn't。 Reece finds herself stranded in Angels Fist for a bit and falls in love with the place。 She gets herself a job that she loves and even a feisty boyfriend, Brody。Brody is sweet, aggravating and funny。 Who wouldn't love him。Reece witnesses a murder and no one but Brody believes her。 T This is the first book I have read from Nora Roberts。 I really liked it。The main character Reece is awesome。 Her spirit, tenacity, strength, and even her stubbornness is great。 She has some problems, but who doesn't。 Reece finds herself stranded in Angels Fist for a bit and falls in love with the place。 She gets herself a job that she loves and even a feisty boyfriend, Brody。Brody is sweet, aggravating and funny。 Who wouldn't love him。Reece witnesses a murder and no one but Brody believes her。 Their connection and interaction with each other is the best。 I love the teasing banter and the fun of this relationship。 As time goes on and Reece feels like she is losing her mind Brody stands by her side, knowing that she is not insane。In the end I did not guess the murder but I am glad that I was wrong because whom I thought was the murder I actually did not want it to be since I really liked his character。Rating: 4 stars。 。。。more